The Platform Paradox: Why Building on Rented Land Is Marketing's Biggest Mistake

In partnership with

Here's a terrifying thought experiment:

What if LinkedIn shut down your company page tomorrow? Or TikTok banned your account? Or Twitter's algorithm suddenly made your posts invisible?

How much of your audience would you actually keep?

For most brands, the answer is "almost none" – and that's the dangerous paradox at the heart of modern marketing.

The Illusion of Ownership

Let's talk about something that happened last week:

LinkedIn shut down the company pages for two major lead-gen providers, instantly cutting them off from thousands of followers they'd spent years cultivating.

Their crime? Violating LinkedIn's ever-changing terms of service.

One CEO desperately tried redirecting followers to their Slack community – failing to realize they were simply jumping from one rented platform to another.

The problem extends far beyond LinkedIn. Brands everywhere are building expensive houses on rented land – pouring resources into platforms they don't control and can't rely on.

Audiences vs. Communities: The Critical Difference

Here's a perspective shift that could transform your marketing strategy:

An audience of 500,000 LinkedIn followers is just borrowed attention. A community of 50,000 engaged members on your own platform is an actual business asset.

The differences are stark:

• Audiences are passive; communities are invested

• Audiences belong to the platform; communities belong to you

• Audiences can disappear overnight; communities remain accessible

• Audiences listen; communities participate

The most valuable brands today aren't just collecting followers – they're creating spaces where customers genuinely want to engage, not just with the brand but with each other.

The Hidden Economics of Platform Dependence

The financial math gets worse every year:

1. Diminishing Organic Reach: Remember when your posts reached most of your followers? Now you're lucky if it's 2-3%.

2. Rising "Pay-to-Play" Costs: Platforms increasingly force brands to pay just to reach the followers they already have.

3. Zero Data Ownership: You can't export those relationships or learn from interactions in meaningful ways.

4. Algorithm Vulnerability: One update can tank your visibility overnight, regardless of content quality.

It's not just inefficient – it's existentially risky. You're building your marketing foundation on quicksand.

The Community Blueprint

Some of the smartest brands have already figured this out:

Gymshark doesn't just sell fitness apparel. They've built exclusive membership spaces where fitness enthusiasts connect, turning customers into community members.

YETI goes beyond selling premium coolers. They've created storytelling platforms where outdoor enthusiasts share adventures that reinforce the brand's identity.

Jeep fosters owner forums where people share off-road experiences and product tips, creating bonds stronger than any ad campaign could.

None of their success depends on LinkedIn, Facebook, or TikTok. Those platforms might serve as bridges, but they're not the destination.

The Implementation Framework

Ready to stop building on rented land? Here's how to start:

1. Own Your Infrastructure Create a space you control – whether it's a private forum, a membership site, or an exclusive content hub.

2. Make It About Them, Not You People don't join communities to hear brand updates. They participate because there's value in being there.

3. Use Social Platforms As Funnels Treat LinkedIn, Instagram and others as pathways to your owned spaces, not as the spaces themselves.

4. Create Real Engagement, Not Broadcast Opportunities A community isn't another marketing channel – it's a place for authentic connection that drives loyalty.

The Bottom Line

The most valuable audience is the one that can't be taken away from you.

As algorithms become more restrictive, platform policies more unpredictable, and organic reach continues to decline, brands that control their own communities will have an insurmountable advantage over those still playing by someone else's rules.

You can keep renting attention on borrowed platforms, or you can start building something that truly belongs to you. The choice – and the risk – is yours.

Until next time...