The New Quality Paradox: Why TikTok Is Beating Hollywood at Its Own Game

In partnership with

When the latest Deloitte report revealed that nearly half of millennials and Gen Z prefer social media content to TV shows and movies, industry executives dismissed it as a passing trend.

They shouldn't have.

This dramatic shift in preference signals something much more profound: the fundamental definition of "quality" in media is being completely rewritten before our eyes.

The Quality Illusion

For decades, the media industry has operated on an unquestioned assumption: higher production values, bigger stars, and larger budgets equal higher quality content. It's why Netflix spent $30 million per episode on "The Crown" and why Hollywood blockbusters routinely cost $200+ million.

But what if this equation is increasingly irrelevant to how consumers actually make choices?

Media analyst Doug Shapiro argues that when someone chooses to scroll through TikTok rather than open Netflix, they're demonstrating that, in that moment, TikTok is the higher quality option. Not objectively "better" in traditional terms, but better suited to their specific needs and context.

The New Quality Attributes

Today's content consumers are weighing entirely different factors when making viewing decisions:

1. Creator Connection vs. Celebrity Viewers often feel stronger bonds with creators they've "grown up with" than with distant Hollywood stars. This parasocial relationship creates a perception of authenticity that big-budget productions can't replicate.

2. Relevance vs. Production Value Highly targeted content that speaks directly to specific interests or communities often wins against broadly appealing but generic professional content.

3. Low-Friction Consumption vs. Commitment The mental energy required to choose and commit to a 30-minute show is significantly higher than scrolling through short-form content—and this "cognitive cost" matters more than we realize.

4. Algorithmic Personalization vs. Linear Programming Content platforms that learn individual preferences and serve hyper-personalized recommendations create a perception of quality through relevance rather than objective production standards.

The Industry Blind Spot

Traditional media companies are struggling to adapt because they fundamentally misunderstand the shift taking place. They see TikTok and YouTube as distribution platforms rather than entirely new content formats with different quality standards.

This is similar to how hotel chains initially dismissed Airbnb as a inferior substitute rather than recognizing it was changing the very attributes travelers value in accommodation. When Airbnb introduced "authenticity" and "local experience" as deciding factors, it didn't eliminate the importance of cleanliness and comfort—it just reduced their relative weight in the decision.

Similarly, production value hasn't stopped mattering in media—it just matters less than it used to, while other attributes have gained importance.

The Strategic Response

For brands and content creators, this shift demands a complete rethinking of content strategy:

1. Attribute Mapping Identify the specific quality attributes your audience values most in different contexts. Don't assume that traditional markers of quality (celebrity endorsements, high production value) still carry the same weight.

2. Context-Aware Creation Recognize that the same person may have entirely different quality standards depending on their situation, device, location, and available time. Design content for specific contexts rather than abstract quality ideals.

3. Friction Reduction Lower the mental energy required to engage with your content. The cognitive cost of decision-making is a major factor in what people choose to consume—even when they have objectively "better" options available.

4. Creator DNA Develop authentic creator personalities even within traditional media formats. The human connection trumps production polish for many viewers.

The Bottom Line

The redefinition of "quality" in media isn't a temporary disruption—it's a fundamental and permanent shift in how consumers make choices. Companies that cling to legacy definitions of quality will continue to invest enormous resources in attributes that carry decreasing weight in consumer decisions.

The winners in this new landscape won't necessarily be those with the biggest budgets or the most impressive production capabilities. They'll be those who understand that quality is ultimately defined by what consumers choose when presented with options.

And increasingly, they're choosing TikTok over Hollywood.

Until next time...