The Invented Problems Paradox: Why Your Brain Creates Drama When Life Is Too Good

In partnership with

A tweet I came across last week stopped me in my tracks:

"Your brain will invent fake problems for you if you don't go out and find real ones."

At first glance, it seems counterintuitive. Why would our brains – supposedly designed to help us survive and thrive – deliberately create problems that don't exist?

But the more I thought about it, the more I recognized this pattern in myself and virtually every high-performer I know.

The Evolutionary Explanation

Our brains evolved during millions of years of constant threat and scarcity. For our ancestors, relaxation wasn't just a luxury – it was dangerous. Those who stayed vigilant survived; those who didn't became lunch.

This explains why even when everything in our lives is going well, we find ourselves:

• Replaying awkward social interactions from years ago

• Inventing elaborate worst-case scenarios about the future

• Creating drama in otherwise healthy relationships

• Finding flaws in our accomplishments that nobody else notices

The Success Paradox

The most accomplished people often suffer from this most acutely. As external challenges are conquered, the mind turns inward to find new threats.

This is why:

• CEOs obsess over minor competitive threats while ignoring major wins

• Celebrities struggle with increasing anxiety despite achieving their dreams

• High-achievers report feeling like impostors despite objective success

• Retirees often experience depression after leaving demanding careers

The absence of actual problems doesn't bring peace – it creates a vacuum our minds rush to fill with imaginary ones.

The Antidote: Productive Challenge

The solution isn't to create unnecessary drama or return to a life of constant stress. Instead, it's about channeling our brain's problem-solving machinery toward productive challenges:

1. Physical Challenges Whether it's training for a marathon, learning a martial art, or simply taking daily walks in nature, physical exertion gives our threat-detection systems something concrete to focus on.

2. Learning Challenges Mastering a new skill – whether programming, painting, or playing piano – presents our brains with solvable problems that create flow and satisfaction.

3. Service Challenges Engaging with real-world problems bigger than ourselves – through volunteering, mentoring, or community involvement – provides perspective that makes invented problems fade away.

4. Creative Challenges Building, making, writing, and creating all give our minds constructive puzzles to solve rather than destructive ones to ruminate on.

The Implementation Strategy

To apply this insight to your own life, try this simple approach:

1. Audit Your Worries When anxiety strikes, ask: "Is this a real problem I can solve, or one my brain has invented?" Simply recognizing the difference creates valuable distance.

2. Schedule Challenge Time Block at least 2-3 hours weekly for activities that stretch your capabilities – physical, mental, or creative challenges that fully engage your problem-solving faculties.

3. Embrace Productive Struggle When facing genuine challenges, resist the urge to escape. The productive discomfort of real problems is the antidote to the destructive discomfort of imagined ones.

4. Create a "Done List" Each day, document problems you've actually solved and progress you've made. This reminds your brain that real challenges exist and are being addressed.

The Bottom Line

The most successful people aren't those who avoid problems – they're those who deliberately choose which problems are worth their attention.

By consciously selecting meaningful challenges rather than letting our minds manufacture artificial ones, we redirect our innate problem-solving machinery toward growth rather than anxiety.

So next time you find yourself inventing scenarios to worry about, remember: your brain needs real problems to solve. Give it some.

Until next time...