From Midnight Munchies to $200M Cookie Empire: Insomnia's Sleepless Success Story

In partnership with

Ever had that moment at 1 AM when you're craving something sweet but everything's closed?

So did Seth Berkowitz, a UPenn sophomore in 2002. But instead of just complaining about it, he spotted a gap in the market that would eventually be worth $200 million.

The $150 Side Hustle

Picture this: It's a freezing night in Philadelphia. Seth and his friends are doing what college students do best – staying up way too late playing video games and ordering delivery.

But after opening the door to yet another pizza delivery guy, Seth had a thought that would change his life:

"Why is it always pizza? Why can't I get warm cookies delivered right now?"

With just $150 of baking supplies, Seth started experimenting with recipes in his college apartment. No fancy equipment. No business plan. Just a simple idea: warm cookies delivered late at night when nothing else is open.

From Dorm Room to Domination

The early days were pure hustle:

• Baking cookies himself

• Handing out flyers door-to-door

• Delivering every order personally

At first, he got three orders a night. Then a student newspaper wrote about him, and suddenly he was filling 80 orders nightly. By semester's end, his little side hustle had netted $10,000 in profit.

A week before graduation, Seth signed the lease on his first physical store in Syracuse, NY.

Today? Insomnia Cookies has over 260 locations across three countries.

The Anti-Crumbl Strategy

What's fascinating about Insomnia's growth is how differently they've approached the market compared to competitors like Crumbl.

While Crumbl built their brand on constant novelty (new flavors every week), Insomnia took the opposite approach:

1. Consistency Over Novelty

   • Core menu that never changes

   • Customers know exactly what to expect

   • Creating deep trust rather than excitement

2. Location Over Social Media

   • Strategic placement near college campuses

   • Becoming part of campus culture

   • Building community connections vs. viral moments

The Sleepless Loyalty Machine

What truly separates Insomnia isn't just their late hours – it's their approach to building loyalty:

👉️ The CookieMagic Membership

For $9.99/month, customers get a free cookie every day, free delivery, and exclusive deals.

This genius model:

• Creates consistent revenue ($9.99 × 12 = $120/year per member)

• Drives repeat visits (the "I already paid for it" effect)

• Builds habits (daily cookie runs become routine)

👉️ Community Integration

Insomnia doesn't just sell to college students – they become part of college life:

• Free cookies during finals week

• Graduation celebrations

• Sponsoring campus events

• Partnering with student organizations

The Business Model Behind the Magic

Looking deeper, Insomnia's success comes down to four core principles:

1. Operating When Others Don't

   • Finding value in "dead time" (10PM-3AM)

   • Capturing 100% of a small market beats fighting for 1% of a large one

2. Margin Mastery

   • Low ingredient costs (flour, sugar, chocolate)

   • High markup potential (a $3 cookie costs pennies to make)

   • Minimal staffing needs (2-3 employees can run a location)

3. Subscription Economics

   • Predictable revenue through CookieMagic

   • Trading margin for volume and consistency

   • Creating a psychological commitment device

4. Location Arbitrage

   • Targeting high-foot-traffic areas with lower-than-average commercial rents

   • College towns offer dense populations of ideal customers

   • Becoming "institution" status grants competitive immunity

The Bigger Lesson

Seth Berkowitz didn't start with a grand vision to build a cookie empire. He started by solving a problem he personally experienced, with the minimal resources available to him.

The path from $150 to $200 million wasn't about revolutionary technology or massive funding rounds. It was about:

• Testing a simple idea

• Proving it worked

• Reinvesting profits

• Repeating at bigger scale

For entrepreneurs, the Insomnia story teaches us that timing and positioning can matter more than the product itself. After all, cookies aren't exactly an innovative product – but cookies delivered at 2 AM to a hungry college student? That's a different story entirely.

Until next time...